(Editor’s note: This article on Max Clark was requested by one of our readers on “X”, @inktown123)
Max Clark entered the 2023 MLB Draft as one of the most celebrated high school players in the country. A left-handed hitting outfielder from Franklin, Indiana, Clark was lauded as a potential five-tool talent with exceptional athleticism. MLB Pipeline noted that he had “four tools that grade as at least plus, starting with his hitting ability,” which some scouts even viewed as a plus-plus tool.
Coming out of high school, he boasted a sweet lefty swing and a mature, line-drive approach geared to use the whole field. This advanced hit tool, paired with his double-plus speed and strong arm, made Clark the best Indiana prep prospect in decades (Fun fact: It marked the second time the Detroit drafted a player out of Indiana so high. LHP Pat Underwood was drafted 2nd overall by the Tigers out of Kokomo High School in 1976).
He drew effusive praise for rising to big moments, for example, starring for Team USA’s U18 national team, and was even in the mix for the No.1 overall pick before the draft.
Pre-Draft Board Discussion
On many draft boards, Clark was neck-and-neck with North Carolina outfielder Walker Jenkins as the top prep position player of 2023. The two had come up together on Team USA and were constantly compared. In the end, the Tigers selected Clark with the 3rd overall pick (Jenkins went 5th to Minnesota), surprising some pundits who expected Detroit to favor a college bat that was available in Wyatt Langford, or Jenkins’ higher power potential.
The consensus was that Jenkins had more raw power and a more patient power-hitter’s profile, whereas Clark offered superior speed, defense, and a hit-over-power offensive game. As MLB.com’s Jim Callis explained, “Jenkins…has more power and controls the strike zone better than Clark, who has superior speed and arm strength and is a no-doubt center fielder.”
In other words, Clark projected as an elite up-the-middle defender and table-setter, while Jenkins profiled as a middle-of-the-order slugger, but both were universally seen as elite talents (indeed “two of the five best prospects in baseball” by early 2025)
Beyond the Jenkins comparisons, evaluators likened Clark’s skillset to some current stars. Fangraphs noted that Clark had “sublime feel for contact” and an “old school leadoff hitter’s profile” thanks to his blend of speed and hit tool. Eric Longenhagen even wrote that “Clark has Corbin Carrollʹs high school skill set with a more prototypical build,” referencing the Diamondbacks’ young All-Star outfielder.
Like Carroll, Clark was a speedy left-handed center fielder with advanced bat-to-ball skills, though Clark entered pro ball with a bit more physicality (6’0” and 205 lbs at age 19) Scouts believed this strength would help him produce plenty of extra-base hits even if his swing wasn’t geared for home run loft.
Perfect Game scouts went as far as calling him an “elite level hitter” in the prep ranks. So, the Tigers were confident Clark’s athleticism and work ethic would translate into a well-rounded player, one who could hit for average and on-base percentage, wreak havoc with his speed, and play stellar defense in center field.
The only real question mark was how much power he would grow into over time, a factor that most agreed would determine whether he becomes merely a very good player or a true superstar at the MLB level.
Professional Debut and Minor League Performance
Clark’s pro career began shortly after the draft in summer 2023, and he wasted no time flashing his talent. He debuted in the rookie-level Florida Complex League and steamrolled the competition with a .283 average and .954 OPS in 12 games. That cameo earned him a quick promotion to Low-A Lakeland, though in 11 games there his bat went quiet (a common occurrence for teens adjusting to full-season ball).
Notably, however, Clark showed immediate plate discipline: he drew 12 walks in those 11 games at Lakeland, a positive sign that his advanced approach would carry over. It was far too small a sample to draw conclusions (only 23 total games in 2023), but Clark’s brief debut reinforced scouting reports: excellent strike zone feel, good patience, and speed that played on the bases and in the field (he swiped 5 bags in that span). But Single-A walk rate numbers, depending on the league, play a smaller role.
The 2024 season provided our first extended look at Clark’s development. The Tigers sent the 19-year-old back to Low-A Lakeland, where he quickly emerged as one of the league’s top performers. In 73 games at Lakeland, Clark slashed .286/.386/.421 with 7 home runs, 18 doubles, and 26 stolen bases. He walked nearly as often as he struck out, posting a 14.4% walk rate and 17.4% strikeout rate in Low-A.
That combination of on-base ability and contact skills made him an extremely effective catalyst atop the lineup – in fact, by wRC+ (Weighted Runs Created Plus) he was about 34% better than the average hitter in the Florida State League. Not surprisingly, he was named a FSL mid-season All-Star and the league’s Top MLB Prospect that year.
His manager, Andrew Graham, and Tigers player development staff lauded his ability to make adjustments. After a solid-but-unspectacular first month, Clark “really left the launchpad about a month into the season,” finding his timing and driving the ball gap-to-gap with more authority by mid-May.
His Lakeland stat line (.807 OPS) is even more impressive considering the FSL is a pitcher-friendly environment that suppresses power numbers. As one Tigers report noted, Clark “went yard seven times in a hitting environment that suppresses power,” showing he could still muscle the ball out despite the heavy Florida air and the reputation of the Florida State League not being a power friendly league.
By August 2024, the Tigers promoted Clark to High-A West Michigan for the final five weeks of the season. There, as expected, he encountered more of a challenge. Older, savvier pitchers exposed a few areas for growth.
In 34 games at High-A, Clark hit a more modest .264/.354/.421 with 2 homers. His walk rate dipped to 8.3% and strikeouts rose to about 23% against the better arms in the Midwest League. Even so, he continued to be an above-average hitter (119 wRC+ in that stint) and held his own as one of the youngest players at that level.
Encouragingly, the jump in competition did not overwhelm him, he still produced a .421 slugging percentage at West Michigan, as he matched his doubles and triples total from Low-A in less than half as many games. In other words, once freed from the FSL’s big parks, his gap power continued to play.
Detroit evaluators did note that advanced right-handed pitchers started testing him more with breaking balls, a plan that had some success. Clark “hit just .140…and struck out in a third of at-bats that ended in a righty’s breaking ball” during 2024, exposing some difficulty picking up spin from opposite-handed pitchers.
This is a fairly normal hurdle for young hitters, and not one that dimmed the club’s optimism. It simply highlighted an area for refinement (recognizing breaking pitches earlier and driving them) before he faces Double-A arms, where the spin will increase. Given his aptitude, the Tigers were content to let Clark “marinate a while longer in the low minors” to work on that, figuring he’d be ready for AA Erie by mid-2025.
Plate discipline and contact quality have been hallmarks of Clark’s game, and the stats behind them tell the story. Even as a teenager, he has shown a healthy approach in the box, rarely chasing bad pitches and making a lot of contact when he does swing. In 2024, for example, Clark’s chase rate (swings at pitches outside the zone) in A-ball was in the upper-30s percentage-wise, which is around league-average. Quite impressive for a 19-year-old hitter facing professional pitching.
Meanwhile, his overall contact rate was solid and his strikeout rates remained comfortably below 20%, suggesting he is not overmatched by velocity or fooled often. In fact, “he ran solid contact rates against most pitch types in the FSL and generally didn’t chase much, leading to healthy walk and strikeout rates,” as MLB Pipeline observed. The chart below from his 2023–2025 minor league performances illustrates his plate discipline metrics, including his low swinging-strike percentage and high first-pitch strike recognition, which underpin those strong BB/K numbers:
Minor league plate discipline metrics for Max Clark by season and level. Even as a young pro, Clark has maintained reasonable swing rates and strong contact rates, supporting his high on-base percentages (data source: FanGraphs).
Clark’s batted ball profile has been another point of interest. True to his scouting report, he has mostly employed a line-drive, all-fields approach rather than selling out for home run loft in his swing. As a result, a significant portion of his contact has been on the ground or on a line, with relatively few balls hit as towering flies, a profile geared more toward gaps and speed than immediate home run totals.
He has worked on his swing a bit since being drafted and in this video, Clark wanted to more thump on his swing that works with his short stroke. The video below helps explain his performance in 2024.
In 2024 at Lakeland, nearly 50% of his batted balls were grounders, while roughly 26% were fly balls (the rest being line drives) according to tracked data. This higher ground-ball rate helped keep his homer count modest. But it’s not necessarily a negative. Many young hitters add more loft as they mature and learn which pitches they can pull in the air. Clark had already shown flashes of turning on the ball by the end of 2024. He began to pull more long fly balls when he got comfortable, hitting all seven of his Low-A homers after the first month of the season.
The key is that he doesn’t prematurely sacrifice his contact quality for power. His average exit velocities so far have been around league-average for A-ball, and he’s recorded plenty of hard-hit liners (in fact, by one account about 36% of his balls in play in 2024 were categorized as “hard hit.”) But because he’s often content to use the opposite field and stay short to the ball, some of those are low liners or grounders through the hole rather than airborne drives.
The spray chart data shows a pretty balanced distribution of hits to all fields. The following graphic summarizes some of these batted-ball tendencies, including his ground ball vs. fly ball rates and line drive percentage at each level:
Max Clark’s batted-ball profile by level (2023–2025). The data shows his ratios of ground balls, fly balls, and line drives, as well as pull vs. opposite-field contact. In 2024, roughly half of his balls in play were on the ground, which, combined with an all-fields approach, kept his home run count modest.
Despite the lack of eye-popping homer totals so far, the Tigers are not concerned – if anything, they are encouraged that Clark sticks to a consistent approach. As one team report noted, Clark “presently concentrates on making hard contact rather than launching balls,” and his bat speed and strength project for “at least 20-homer power” in time as he learns to elevate selectively.
His 2024 results back this up: many of his doubles and triples would likely have left the park in a more hitter-friendly setting, and his offseason strength gains have already started to translate. Tigers officials also point out that Clark has “already added strength from his amateur days” and as he continues that trajectory and adds a bit more loft, “there’s the potential for at least average power” down the road (around 15–20 homers annually) In short, the power will come. And Clark’s 2024 showed hints of that without him abandoning the contact-first approach that makes him so effective.
2025 Progress and Developmental Trends
Now in 2025, his age-20 season, Clark has continued to build on those strengths in High-A. He opened the year back in West Michigan and got off to a scorching start in April. Through his first month-plus, he hit well over .300 and was getting on base nearly half the time.
At one point early on, he carried a .351 average and .446 OBP, demonstrating that pitchers in High-A were having a hard time keeping him off the basepaths. Perhaps most remarkably, in the first several weeks he had walked more than he struck out – for instance, by early May his walk rate was around 20.7% while his strikeout rate was just 13.2%
Such plate discipline is extraordinary for a 20-year-old and ranked among the best in the league. As the Whitecaps’ leadoff man, Clark was “raking and raking some more,” consistently giving his team quality at-bats. One minor critique was that he wasn’t yet very aggressive in using his speed on the bases (only a couple of steals through April despite his elite run times. The organization has encouraged him to learn the craft of basestealing and take more chances, figuring that will come with experience and confidence.
In the late spring, Clark hit a bit of a lull for the first time. Over a four-week span from mid-May to mid-June, his numbers cooled off: a reminder that development is not completely linear. In that stretch of about 19 games, he batted only .206 with 1 home run. Fatigue and the league’s adjustments to him likely played a part. Pitchers began challenging him inside more aggressively and sequencing their breaking balls to get him fishing out front.
However, even during this “slump,” the underlying signs remained positive. Lynn Henning noted that one should “ignore the [batting average] numbers” from that stretch – “Clark still has more walks (23) than strikeouts (18) during those past 19 games,” he wrote, highlighting that Clark’s plate discipline held strong despite the dip in hits. Moreover, Clark continued to hit the ball hard consistently. His hard-hit contact didn’t falter, suggesting he was smoking some balls right at fielders.
It’s the kind of soft slump that actually heartens the Tigers’ front office: rather than expanding his zone or pressing, Clark stuck to his approach and trusted the process. Unsurprisingly, the Tigers aren’t worried at all. In fact, as of this writing, it is likely Clark’s overall performance in High-A has been strong enough to warrant a promotion to Double-A Erie.
With the Whitecaps clinching a first-half title, Detroit is ready to challenge their outfielder with the next level of pitching. By all accounts, Clark is handling High-A’s lessons with maturity and is on the verge of that next step.
Long-Term Ceiling and Outlook: “He’ll Be Fine”
With roughly one year of pro ball under his belt, Max Clark’s long-term outlook remains as exciting as ever for the Tigers. He has validated the pre-draft reports that pegged him as an advanced hitter. His combination of bat control, pitch recognition, and speed is a fantastic foundation to build upon.
As a prospect, Clark now sits among the top handful of outfielders in the minor leagues. Most outlets rank him in the top 20 overall. We have him number 2 just behind Kevin McGonigle. MLB.com’s rankings to start 2025 placed him as the No. 7 prospect in baseball. The ingredients for a future impact player are all visible.
From what I’ve seen live, Clark’s arm strength and range could project him to left field at higher levels if needed. But his baseball IQ and overall instincts strongly support his long-term fit in center.
What’s especially noticeable is how consistently he handles the details, whether it’s executing situational hitting to move a runner over or positioning himself perfectly on defense. While we focus on the highlights in our nightly clips on Twitter, it’s those small, winning plays that quietly reinforce just how advanced his overall game already is.
The main question that every evaluator brings up is Clark’s power ceiling. Will he develop enough pop to become an MLB star, or is he more of a speedy sparkplug who hits line drives and occasional homers? The consensus is that Clark will grow into solid power, even if he’s unlikely to ever be a 30+ home run slugger.
As MLB Pipeline summarized, at this stage he’s “hit-over-power…His exit velocities were around average…and his power didn’t quite pop in slugging numbers due to a high ground-ball rate.”
Going forward, incremental strength gains and swing adjustments (adding a bit more loft when appropriate) could unlock average or above-average power. Scouts see 15–20 homer potential in him down the road which, combined with 30+ doubles and 30 steals, would make for a pretty dynamic leadoff hitter profile.
Fangraphs aptly noted that Clark “has special hit tool projection and speed…[he] projects as an everyday center fielder whose pathway to superstardom is dependent on him either developing more home run power…or having elite plate discipline and on-base ability.”
Plate Discipline
The good news: if there’s one thing he’s already showing, it’s elite plate discipline. His advanced approach might well carry him to an excellent OBP and allow him to be an offensive force even with modest home run totals. And if the power does exceed expectations (perhaps he taps into more pull-side lift in his early 20s), then his upside could be that of a superstar.
As Tigers officials like to remind people, even a player like Carroll was not known for prodigious power in the minors. Yet a combination of contact, speed, and smart adjustments turned him into a 25-homer threat in the majors. Clark has a similar chance to surprise people with how his power evolves. While this reference is dated, Lou Whitaker never hit for power until later in his career.
Of course, there are risks, as with any prospect. One conceivable downside scenario is that Clark’s bat peaks as more of a contact/speed type without enough impact to be a true everyday cornerstone (some pessimistic observers have wondered if he could become a light-hitting, defense-first player.) Chris, myself, and the rest of the staff have discussed this at length.
But given his work ethic, knack for adjustments, and the flashes of gap power he’s already shown, it’s far more likely that he will reach his potential as an above-average regular.
Even the cautious voices acknowledge that Clark’s floor is relatively high because he can impact the game in so many ways (running, defense, on-base skills). If the power is the last tool to come around, the Tigers are content to be patient. Development isn’t a race, and all signs indicate Clark is progressing exactly as hoped by the organization’s standards of controlling the strike zone.
Different development progress
It’s fair to note that Tigers fans have seen prep outfielders with tools before. Players like Derek Hill come to mind, but the bar is higher now. Clark brings not just athleticism, but a more refined approach at the plate, and better feel for the game.
Do fans wish Detroit had drafted someone like Langford, who rocketed through the minors and is a regular at the big league level? Absolutely. But that doesn’t mean Clark isn’t on the right path.
By every measure, he’s progressing just fine, showing growth and maturity at each stop. The Tigers have been very strict so far about keeping players at a certain level, with Toledo being the final step.
Detroit fans have ample reason to be excited about Max Clark’s trajectory. He has lived up to the pre-draft hype as a disciplined hitter with plus speed and defense, and he has shown maturity in handling both success and adversity early in his pro career, even if at times performances like Kevin McGonigle and Josue Briceno overshadow him at West Michigan.
The optimistic angle is well-founded. There might be some ups and downs as he climbs the ladder, but nothing in his performance so far suggests any red flags.
The Tigers believed in Clark’s talent when they made him a top-3 pick, and his development to date has only strengthened that belief. Max Clark will be fine, and if he reaches his ceiling, he could be the dynamic homegrown outfielder Tigers who would join Riley Greene and Parker Meadows as players who can be a steady major league performer.
Hey Detroit Tigers fans! If you enjoy Tigers Minor League Report and want to help us keep bringing you the latest updates and in-depth analysis, consider contributing to our efforts. We operate entirely on a volunteer basis, and every bit of support goes a long way. You can donate to us directly via our GoFundMe or become a valued member by subscribing to our YouTube channel. Or take your fandom to the next level by joining our Patreon community. Additionally, you can shop for some awesome gear at our TMLR store. Your support helps us continue our mission to provide you with quality content on all things Tigers Minor League. Thank you!
Chris Brown 
Jerry McKennan